• About
    • About Us
    • Staff
    • Board of Directors
      • Meet the Board
      • Board Documents
    • Annual Report
    • Board of Advisors
    • Contact Us
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Our Work
    • Wins for the Bay
    • Bay Issues
    • Pro Bono Projects
    • Services Provided
    • Get Legal Help
    • CLA Testimonials
    • CLA’s Legal Documents
  • Get Involved
    • Volunteer
    • Job Opportunities
    • Get Legal Help
  • Home
  • Guides + Reports
    • Guides + Reports
    • Maryland Violations Tracker
  • News
    • Top News
    • CLA In The News
    • CLA Publications
    • CLA News
    • BAY BRIEF Newsletter
    • Calendar
  • Support
    • Donate
    • Foundation Partners
    • Planning for the Future
    • Become A Law Firm Partner
    • Gifts Of Stocks + Securities

Contact Us | Donate

Chesapeake Legal AllianceChesapeake Legal Alliance
  • About
    • About Us
    • Staff
    • Board of Directors
      • Meet the Board
      • Board Documents
    • Annual Report
    • Board of Advisors
    • Contact Us
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Our Work
    • Wins for the Bay
    • Bay Issues
    • Pro Bono Projects
    • Services Provided
    • Get Legal Help
    • CLA Testimonials
    • CLA’s Legal Documents
  • Get Involved
    • Volunteer
    • Job Opportunities
    • Get Legal Help
  • Home
  • Guides + Reports
    • Guides + Reports
    • Maryland Violations Tracker
  • News
    • Top News
    • CLA In The News
    • CLA Publications
    • CLA News
    • BAY BRIEF Newsletter
    • Calendar
  • Support
    • Donate
    • Foundation Partners
    • Planning for the Future
    • Become A Law Firm Partner
    • Gifts Of Stocks + Securities
Home CLA PublicationsEPA’s Clean Water Rule rollback: What does this mean for the Bay?
EPA’s Clean Water Rule rollback: What does this mean for the Bay?
First Light in the marsh. Smith island, Chesapeake Bay Md. I was out before the sunrise on Smith Island in the Chesapeake bay and planted my tripod and waited for the sun. I loved the first light in the grass and the reflected clouds and sky

EPA’s Clean Water Rule rollback: What does this mean for the Bay?

Jan 24, 2020 | CLA Publications, Top News |

We at the Chesapeake Legal Alliance, like so many Americans who want safe water and care about protecting valuable habitat, are deeply concerned by the new Navigable Waters Protection Rule released this week by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Far from being protective, this Rule eliminates federal Clean Water Act protections for countless miles of streams and acres of wetlands. The full effect of this rollback will take years to fully understand but will impact everything from the safety of your drinking water, to the quality of your favorite trout stream or fishing pond, to the protection of endangered fish, amphibians, birds, and other species.

But what will this mean for the Chesapeake Bay? A few things:

Restoring the Bay Just Got More Difficult. The six Bay states and the District of Columbia have been working to reach nitrogen, phosphorus, and sediment pollution reduction targets by 2025 under the current Chesapeake Bay restoration plan. While the Bay has shown some water quality improvements in recent years, this restoration plan is not on track to meet the 2025 targets. What we need now is more help, not less. By reducing the number of waterways that receive Clean Water Act protection, we can now expect to have more pollution entering the Chesapeake Bay just as states are supposed to be significantly accelerating the pace of pollution reductions. This means that some of the hard work that Bay watershed residents and volunteers are doing and the hard earned taxpayer dollars that are going toward Bay restoration projects are in jeopardy of being offset or negated by increases in pollution due to the new rollback.

Pristine Areas and Critical Habitat Are Now At Risk. In 2015, EPA issued the Clean Water Rule. This rule provided science-based guidance clarifying which waterways are protected by the Clean Water Act. EPA’s new rule, which replaces the 2015 version, ignores the basics of ecology and hydrology and removes protections for critical waterways. As a result of this rollback, two types of waterways are no longer protected under the Clean Water Act: (1) isolated wetlands, including the thousands of non-tidal wetlands scattered throughout the Delmarva Peninsula known as “Delmarva Potholes”; and (2) small headwater streams that only flow during portions of the year. But these waterways play a key role in the hydrologic system. Wetlands filter pollution and seasonal streams connect waterways and recharge groundwater. Both types of waterways are important habitat for wildlife. EPA’s new rule allows these waterways to be destroyed, filled in for development, or loaded with pollution without ANY Clean Water Act oversight. Only time will tell how many additional wetlands and streams will be lost without this protection and how many endangered species will be imperiled because of vanishing habitat.

State Agencies Will Need More Resources. The Clean Water Act depends on the collaboration and cooperation between state and federal agencies and their scientists, engineers, and other staff working to keep our waters clean. With this new rollback, the federal government will no longer protect countless miles of streams and acres of wetlands, leaving the state agencies to do this work themselves. At best, this means that in some states, the state environmental agency will need substantially more resources to fill in the gap left by EPA. At worst, in other states that never established state law protections of these wetlands and small streams, there will be no protection at all; in these states, lawmakers must immediately decide whether they can afford to build entire new divisions to protect their waterways and will need to pass new laws to do so.

Drinking Water Is Now Less Safe. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Nowhere is this more evident than in the context of drinking water protection. It is dramatically less expensive to protect lands surrounding drinking water sources – as New York City has done in the Catskill Mountains – than it is to remediate waters already polluted by chemicals or attempt to drill deeper or build further to locate new water supplies. By repealing federal protection for so many pristine waterways, towns and cities will have a harder time keeping their drinking water safe for residents or finding new sources of clean water to drink.

The Chesapeake Legal Alliance will continue to monitor what this rollback means for Chesapeake Bay restoration, the protection of drinking water for Bay communities, and habitat for fish and wildlife in the region.

By: Evan Isaacson, Director of Policy & Research, Chesapeake Legal Alliance
Services: Analysis and Advice Legislation and Policy
Issues: Municipal and Industrial Waste Water Public Health Septic and Sewer Systems Stormwater Runoff Hazardous Waste + Toxics Land Use + Habitat Protection Fisheries + Oysters Environmental Justice Energy + Climate Change Bay Cleanup + Government Transparency Agricultural Pollution
« Previous Post
Next Post »

You also might be interested in

Press Release: NPDES Citizen Guide

Jul 24, 2017

CLA and MRC are also hosting a companion training webinar[...]

CLA Featured in MD Bar Journal

May 27, 2015

“Legal Muscle for the Bay”, authored by CLA, is the lead[...]

BAY BRIEF – April 2021

BAY BRIEF – April 2021

May 14, 2021

Check out the latest edition of our Bay Brief! In[...]

News + Updates

  • CLA News
  • CLA Publications
  • Wins for the Bay
  • BAY BRIEF Newsletter
  • Annual Report
  • All News

Recent Posts

  • BAY BRIEF March 2023 March 22, 2023
  • BAY BRIEF February 2023 March 22, 2023
  • BAY BRIEF January 2023 March 21, 2023

Contact Us

We're currently offline. Send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Send Message
Need legal assistance? We Can Help

Contact Us

Chesapeake Legal Alliance
106 Ridgely Avenue
Annapolis, Maryland 21401

P: (410) 216-9441
F: (410) 216-7077

Charity Navigator
Strategic Plan
Annual Report

© 2023 Chesapeake Legal Alliance. All Rights Reserved. Website by The Downstream Project

  • Bay Issues
  • Pro Bono Projects
  • Services Provided
  • Get Legal Help
  • CLA Testimonials
  • CLA Legal Documents
Prev Next